". . . and having done all . . . stand firm." Eph. 6:13

Newsletter

The News You Need

Subscribe to The Washington Stand

X

Looming Supreme Court-Packing Clash Wouldn’t Be First Time Congress Changed Structure of Nation’s Top Tribunal

Article banner image
Print Icon
November 17, 2026
News Analysis

Top leaders of the incoming Democratic majorities in the 120th Congress are expected to push for passage of a plan to restructure the nation’s highest court to enable a future chief executive from their party to appoint a new majority favorable to their policies.

Rep. James Clyburn, the South Carolina Democrat who currently serves as House minority leader and is expected to occupy a powerful position in the new Congress, is among the most vocal of advocates for the incoming majority to approve legislation expanding the court from its present nine members to 13.

“I think we are in a position now that calls for some significant actions taken by the Congress and we ought to expand, and 13 is a pretty good number. A baker’s dozen, it would be a good number to have on the court,” Clyburn said in September as the 2026 midterm election campaign began accelerating toward the November 3 Democratic tsunami.

So does former Vice President Kamala Harris, who recently told the National Urban League, “We need to revisit the point of expanding the court to 13 justices like we have 13 district courts.” In the same speech, Harris also endorsed proposals to abolish the Electoral College and grant statehood to Puerto Rico and the District of Columbia.

President Donald Trump is expected to veto any legislation sent to him by Congress between now and the end of his second term in the White House in January 2029 that repacks the court, abolishes the Electoral College, or converts Puerto Rico and D.C. into states, each with two senators and multiple members of the House of Representatives.

If Democrats keep their congressional majorities and elect the next chief executive in 2028, those three reforms alone would be sufficient to end the United States as a democratic republic and convert it to something much closer to a direct democracy like those opposed by the Founders.

But a 2027 court-packing effort by the Democrats would not be the first time Congress has considered re-arranging the nation’s highest court. In 1937, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt (FDR), frustrated by the conservative majority on the bench that opposed much of his New Deal programs, asked Congress to approve a comprehensive reform package. That package would have expanded the court to as many as 15 members.

Despite Congress being solidly in control of his party, FDR’s proposal was rejected in the legislature. Opposition from Republicans and numerous Democrats, including several prominent New Deal backers, killed the proposal in the House, while a critical report by the Senate Judiciary Committee doomed it in the upper chamber.

The high court was thus kept at the same nine justices that sit today, and it is necessary to go all the way back to 1869 to find the last time Congress opted to rearrange the chairs behind the illustrious bench. In that year, Congress decided it was time to fix the number of justices at nine, as it has remained to the present. Before 1869, however, there were multiple changes.

At the outset of the republic in 1789, the Constitution specified a chief justice and five associate justices on the bench. Then in 1801, following the election of the Democratic-Republican Party presidential candidate Thomas Jefferson, the defeated Federalist Party controlled by outgoing President John Adams passed the Judiciary Reform Act that barred filling the next vacancy, thus dropping the court to five members. But the next Congress, which Jefferson’s party controlled, restored the sixth seat.

In the successive years, more changes were made by Congress:

  • In 1807, Congress moved to expand the court to seven justices due to the westward expansion of the nation into Tennessee, Kentucky, and Ohio. The new justice was required to live in the newly created seventh circuit.
  • Three decades later, Congress, again responding to steady westward expansion, created the eighth and ninth circuits that covered, respectively, Kentucky, Tennessee and Missouri, and Alabama, Arkansas, Louisiana, and Mississippi.
  • During the Civil War in 1863, Congress added a 10th justice and a 10th circuit to accommodate cases arising in California and Oregon. Politics played a role in that action as well because President Abraham Lincoln wanted another strongly Unionist justice on the court, a wish granted by his Republican supporters in Congress.
  • Politics entered again three years later as the ninth and 10th justices were removed from the Supreme Court by Congress in 1866 via the prevention of new appointments by President Andrew Johnson, the Democratic vice president who succeeded Lincoln following his assassination.
  • Civil War General Ulysses Grant, a Republican, was elected president in 1868 and the next year another GOP-controlled Congress decided it was time to fix the court at nine seats.

Because they alone nominate Supreme Court justices and the chief justice, presidents have often been a decisive influence on the high court, but not always, according to USA Facts. President Jimmy Carter never had the opportunity to appoint a member of the Supreme Court. By contrast, FDR appointed eight justices during his 12-year tenure in the Oval Office, including one who he promoted to chief justice.

Republican presidents have appointed nearly eight of every 10 justices since 1869. The nine by FDR is the most, closely followed by Republican William Howard Taft, who appointed six and Republican Dwight Eisenhower who appointed five. Chief executives who appointed four justices include Grant, Ronald Reagan, Grover Cleveland, William Henry Harrison, Warren Harding, Harry Truman, and Richard Nixon.

Support the work of TWS with a gift to FRC

Mark Tapscott
Mark Tapscott is senior congressional analyst at The Washington Stand.


RELATED



Support the work of TWS with a gift to FRC