On How Not to End a War
In war, “no plan of operations extends with any degree of certainty beyond the first encounter with the main force of the enemy,” Prussian Field Marshall Helmuth von Moltke wrote in his 1871 essay “On Strategy.” So it should come as no surprise that eight months of conflict have thrown both the American and Iranian regimes into some degree of disarray.
The Trump administration felt this disarray most acutely at the ballot box, where voters lashed out in anger over months of high gas prices and delivered control of Congress to the opposing party.
Nine days after the loss, President Donald Trump reassigned Vice President J.D. Vance from never-ending negotiations with Iran to domestic corruption. This was a move to effectively freeze the uneasy status quo in place. As Trump explained, “We don’t need a deal with Iran. Those days have long since passed. We’ve got their money, Hundreds of Billions of Dollars, and we’ve got their Strait.”
Disarray in the Iranian regime is evident in the various factions still vying for control, after the initial American strikes liquidated their leadership. On Sunday, Iranian Parliament Speaker Mohammad Bagher Qalibaf described the current relationship between the two nations as “neither war nor peace,” offering “seven reasonable conditions” for peace, which were anything but.
To this, Kazem Gharibabadi, Iran’s deputy foreign minister for legal and international affairs, responded, “My personal belief is that from a legal perspective, we are still in a state of war and not in a neither-war-nor-peace situation.”
Such a public contradiction of the figure leading negotiations with the United States undermines the negotiating position. It also has the virtue of better reflecting reality.
Consider the following facts: on Sunday, Bahrain intercepted Iranian drone strikes launched at U.S. military installations. In response, the U.S. Embassy in Manama issued a security alert advising American citizens to “exercise heightened vigilance due to the increased threat of armed attacks by Iranian-supported Houthis and Iranian efforts to target U.S. government officials and facilities in the region.”
This weekend, Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Secretary Markwayne Mullin shared that “aspirational threats from Iran” to assassinate American figures appear “every single day during our presidential briefings,” with President Trump and his family topping the list.
Recently, U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, the official who oversees U.S. sanctions against Iran, relocated from a Georgetown rowhouse to a military base after an Iranian plot to assassinate him reached “more than an advanced stage.”
On Friday, the X account for the Iranian embassy in South Africa warned two U.S. naval officers returning from deployment, “We will find you.” It previously accused the men of ordering strikes on a school, “killing 168 innocent children” and concluded, “Don’t they have children of their own?”
Meanwhile, the United Kingdom Maritime Trade Operations (UKMTO) on Sunday kept the Middle East maritime threat level at “severe” due to “IRGC attacks, attempted attacks, and/or harassment activity” in and around the Strait of Hormuz.
In summary, Iranian forces continue to shoot at American forces. Iran continues to plot the death of the American president, senior American officials, and individual American military officers. Iran persists in its illegal harassment of international maritime trade. These are all acts of war. U.S.-Iran relations can certainly not be classified as “peace.”
Can the current relations be classified as “neither war nor peace”? Answering the question would require defining such a term, but that is absurd because the term is nonsense. Much like pregnancy, war is a binary condition: it either exists or it does not. Also like pregnancy, the existence of war is determined by actual conditions, not by any announcement of such.
Diplomats employ delicate language to achieve delicate outcomes, and this author does not presume to dictate the diction of diplomats.
However, those committed to the truth ought to recognize the distinction between diplomatic contingencies and reality. “Better is open rebuke than hidden love. Faithful are the wounds of a friend; profuse are the kisses of an enemy” (Proverbs 27:5-6). These proverbs teach us it is more loving to tell a hard truth than to weave a web of comforting lies.
The truth is, however much the Trump administration may wish to appease voters by obtaining peace with Iran, a state of war still exists. All the negotiations, including many predictions that a solution was at hand, have come to naught, largely due to the Iranian regime’s insistence on maintaining the capability to produce a nuclear bomb.
The Trump administration may send home its diplomats. If forced to do so by a Democrat-controlled Congress, the Trump administration may even send home its military. But such unilateral actions do not change the fact that the Iranian regime is still actively plotting the death of Americans, and the death of America’s allies. Until that condition changes, peace cannot prevail.
Indeed, the Islamic Republic of Iran has never considered itself to be at peace with the United States of America; it has simply chosen for decades to bide its time rather than risk an escalatory confrontation it would be sure to lose. Now that confrontation has come, Iran did indeed lose every battle, but now it seeks to win the peace negotiations through sheer stubbornness. Hopefully, America will not abet the Iranian gambit through willful blindness.


