America Already Has Thousands of Data Centers. Guess Who Doesn’t Want Us to Build More?
Alexander Muse knows all about the swelling political and academic opposition to the new generation of data centers needed for the artificial intelligence (AI) era of the internet because he’s been building them across America for several decades.
“We built them in Dallas, Miami, New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, and St. Louis. Thousands of people walked past our buildings every day. They did not protest them. Most did not even know what was inside,” he explains in a recent Substack column.
“That silence was not a cover for some environmental menace. Our data centers were good neighbors. They occupied underused buildings, produced almost no traffic, and bought enormous amounts of electricity from the grid while our cooling systems consumed no water. Servers and telecommunications gear hummed behind anonymous walls while the fiber inside connected businesses and consumers to a rapidly expanding Internet,” he writes.
And here are some more facts Muse points out that will shock many: There are more than 5,000 data centers functioning across the country today, many of which were built during the early stages of the internet boom. As a result, 38% of all Americans live within five miles of one or more such facilities. Eighty-seven percent of these existing data centers were built in urban centers.
Muse presents these facts because they contradict what is being peddled by the increasingly loud and rabid chorus of demands in the mainstream media and in American politics for either an outright ban on construction of new data centers or at least a “temporary” moratorium on such projects.
Much of that opposition to new data centers comes from environmental groups that have long histories of outright opposition to new infrastructure projects like highways, power plants, and commercial enterprises. For example, an AI-based search for such groups with records of opposition to the new and old projects turned up multiple examples.
- The Piedmont Environment Council (PEC) in Virginia joined with another environmental group, Clean Water Action, in opposition during the early 1990s that ultimately killed a planned Disney theme park near the site of the Manassas Battlefield Park, as reported at the time by The Washington Post. The PEC also fought the proposed Bi-County Parkway, which was never built, and has led contemporary opposition to the formerly proposed Digital Gateway data center project. The latter project was canceled in July of this year.
- The Sierra Club in 2017 joined with Earth Justice to fight the proposed expansion of Interstate 70 in the Denver, Colorado, area. In 2022, Sierra Club and the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) combined in a successful fight against Maryland’s Beltway and I?'270 toll-lane plan in 2022. And this year, all three of the groups united to oppose Oracle’s proposed 4-gigawatt data center in Saline Township, Michigan. The Oracle data center is under construction but faces continuous and expensive litigation against it.
- Greenpeace, one of the oldest contemporary environmental activist groups, has long fought coal, oil and gas infrastructure, nuclear power, destructive development, and other projects. It was one of 500 such groups that signed a nationwide data center moratorium letter earlier this year, according to
These are a small selection that is representative of a massive, well-funded movement that routinely receives laudatory crescendos of coverage in media outlets that, according to a new Pew Research Center survey, has heavily influenced public opinion in 2026. “Americans have grown more negative toward the possible environmental and economic effects of data centers since the beginning of the year. And a majority say they’d be uncomfortable if a new data center started operating in their area.”
The generous financing of this anti-data center movement is linked to the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) in Beijing, according to sources, OpenAI and CBS News, cited by Muse:
“OpenAI disclosed a PRC-origin influence operation, nicknamed ‘Data Center Bandwagon,’ that generated posts blaming AI data centers for skyrocketing electricity bills and described the operators as ‘testing narratives against AI infrastructure.’ Entities controlled by Neville Roy Singham, the Shanghai-based financier married to CodePink co-founder Jodie Evans, directed more than $300 million between 2017 and 2023 to six U.S. nonprofits in his political network, and organizations in that ideological ecosystem participated in 21 data-center campaigns across 14 states killing more than $24 billion in proposed projects.
“CBS reported in July that a federal grand jury in Manhattan is investigating Singham’s network for violations of the Foreign Agents Registration Act and tax laws. He denies working directly for Beijing and has not been charged, and the investigation is not a conviction, but a federal grand jury does not convene over rhetoric.”
Whatever the ultimate outcome of that Manhattan grand jury, what is not in doubt are the multiple misrepresentations by the anti-data center movement that appear in most of the campaign’s demonstrations and publications. Muse highlights two claims, in particular, that data centers will cause higher utility costs for the general public and the new facilities’ supposed failure to create new jobs.
Of the former objection, Muse points to a recent study at Columbia University:
“A data center runs around the clock at a high load factor, which means it buys far more electricity per megawatt of capacity than a factory that closes at 5 p.m. Columbia University’s Center on Global Energy Policy reviewed the literature this year and found that the surplus revenue from properly priced large loads can ‘function as a subsidy’ for other customers. One analysis estimated that each additional gigawatt of data-center demand in Pacific Gas & Electric territory could cut average household bills by 1 to 2 percent.”
Of the latter objection, Muse is unsparing:
“The jobs complaint is a category error about infrastructure. Substations, fiber routes, pipelines and transmission lines are valuable because they enable economic activity, not because thousands of people work inside each one. The value of a bridge is not measured by how many people it employs after construction. Data centers deliver construction work, property tax revenue, utility revenue, and the computing capacity on which countless other businesses depend. A factory-style headcount test is a way of saying you do not want the hall.”
The data center moratorium proposals now in vogue in the media, Democrats in Congress, and some Republicans (most notably Senator Josh Hawley of Missouri) are “the activist’s (and China’s) favorite ‘middle ground,’ and it is neither middle nor ground. A ban is not regulation. It is surrender. It prevents regulators from distinguishing a responsible project from a reckless one, thereby simply moving the investment to another state or country. Moratorium politics is designed to look cautious while delivering an outright veto: no permits, no steel, and a press conference about families.”
Like the falsehood that makes it halfway around the world before the truth gets to first base, the movement against new data centers in America is rapidly going forward. Let us pray that truth-tellers like Alexander Muse hit grand slams in this battle.


