We Taught Gen Z to Question Everything. Is AI Getting a Pass?
“ChatGPT,” one young woman told us when we asked where Gen Z goes to find answers about God. Her answer has stuck with me ever since.
In classrooms, around dining room tables, and on TikTok, young people are encouraged to question what they have been taught. For some raised in church, that includes deconstructing their faith: challenging what they believe about God and whether they can trust the Bible.
Questions aren’t the problem. Young people should understand why they believe what they believe. The adults teaching them have a responsibility to help them work through those questions. But if they are willing to challenge Scripture, are they willing to fact-check the answers they get from AI, too?
Research from Barna and Gloo found that roughly two in five Gen Z and millennial adults consider spiritual advice from AI as trustworthy as guidance from a pastor. What is that trust based on?
When a pastor teaches something about God, we can ask him to show us where it comes from in Scripture. We can ask how he reached his conclusion and whether the passage means what he says it means. His title does not make him right. His teaching must be tested against the word of God.
An answer from AI needs testing, too.
I recently asked ChatGPT whether it believed in right and wrong. It told me, “I don’t hold personal beliefs or have a conscience, so I don’t believe in right and wrong the way you do.” It went on to explain that its moral judgments come from its training and the principles guiding its responses.
That made me want to ask more questions. Whose principles? What does it use to decide whether something is right or wrong? And would a young person reading its answer know to ask?
A teenager may be asking it, “Was I born in the wrong body?” or “Is terminating a pregnancy wrong?” These are personal questions with real consequences. We need to know what moral standard AI engines use in the answers they provide, especially when those answers can lead individuals to make irreversible decisions.
During our campus and street interviews with Verity Collective, we have heard truth described as something that depends on the individual. Some young people explain right and wrong through their experiences or whether a decision hurts someone else. Others seem unsure how to explain why they believe certain things are right.
If we decide something is true because it feels right, we may question a biblical teaching we find difficult while accepting an AI answer we agree with. We need to research both.
Even students with a solid faith foundation need help with this.
Barna reported that among teens it classifies as “faith-activated,” its most spiritually engaged group, 49% strongly agree they trust technology and AI to give them helpful information, compared with 29% of teens overall. Forty-six percent of faith-activated teens strongly agree AI feels like a safe place to ask questions they would not ask aloud, compared with 28% of teens overall.
In the same research, parents remained teens’ leading sources of advice about who they are. But parents and pastors should pay attention to students’ willingness to ask AI questions they would not ask aloud. What are they hesitant to bring to us? Have we given them room to ask?
They need adults who will work through difficult questions with them, including questions those adults cannot answer immediately. We should be willing to say, “I don’t know. Let’s look at that together,” and then take the time to do it.
Gen Z needs to know how to read a passage in context, check whether a source says what an answer claims, and test claims about God against Scripture.
As Christians, we believe God’s word is true even when we find it difficult or the people around us disagree. We have a responsibility to explain why we trust the Bible and to make sure our own answers are faithful to it.
Acts 17 describes the Bereans examining the Scriptures daily to see whether what Paul taught them was true. Scripture calls them noble for receiving his message eagerly and examining it against God’s word.
We need to raise a generation of Bereans willing to ask questions and open their Bibles to find out whether what they hear is true.
If we want Gen Z to make informed decisions about what they believe, they must start by testing the answers AI is quick to produce.
Naomi Anderson is the co-founder of Verity Collective, which exists to reach this generation with the unchanging truth of Jesus Christ.

